Skip to main content
The Law School Location Trap – A Tale of Two Students

Input

Modified

Location can outweigh rankings when it comes to job opportunities
Being in a major legal city means easier access to internships, networking, and hiring firms
Law firms prefer local talent, making it harder for out-of-state graduates to compete
Bar passage rates and state-specific legal systems often favor in-state graduates
Attending law school in a legal hub offers long-term career advantages beyond the first job

Imagine two law students, Jake and Sarah. Both were accepted into law schools of similar ranking. One went to a mid-ranked school in a major city, while the other went to a higher-ranked school in a smaller city.

Who do you think had the better job prospects? The answer might surprise you.

This story-based article explores how law school location impacts career success, examining real-world hiring trends and long-term benefits of studying in a legal hub.

Case Study 1: Jake’s Hard Lesson in Location Bias

Jake attended Midwest State Law School, a respectable program ranked in the top 40. He graduated top 5% of his class, aced the bar, and applied to Big Law firms in New York.

But no one was interested.

Why? Firms preferred graduates from local schools like Columbia, NYU, and Fordham. His school had no strong alumni network in NYC, and he lacked the connections needed to break in.

Jake spent months applying, receiving little to no responses. A few firms invited him to interview, but the moment they saw he was from an out-of-state school with no prior experience in the city, he was passed over for a local candidate.

Defeated, Jake applied to firms in his home state, where he finally landed a mid-tier job. Had he gone to a law school in New York, his odds would have been much higher.

Case Study 2: Sarah’s Big City Advantage

Sarah, on the other hand, went to Fordham Law (ranked lower than Jake’s school) in New York City. Though she had a lower GPA, she interned at a top Manhattan firm because of her school’s location and alumni network.

By graduation, Sarah had multiple job offers from NYC firms. Meanwhile, Jake was still struggling to get noticed.

The difference? Sarah was in the right place at the right time.

Even before she graduated, she had built a solid foundation in the NYC legal market through internships, networking events, and mentorship from alumni who already worked at major firms. By her third year, she had multiple summer associate offers, leading to a direct path into Big Law.

Why Location Made the Difference

Sarah’s career advantages weren’t random; they were a direct result of her law school’s geographical proximity to the legal market. She had:

  • Immediate access to top-tier internships that led to job offers.
  • Stronger networking opportunities, attending NYC-based events and firm receptions.
  • Alumni connections that helped her secure interviews.
  • Easier bar passage alignment, as Fordham grads overwhelmingly take the NY bar.
  • More direct exposure to hiring firms, meaning she was on recruiters’ radars long before graduation.

Jake, despite his higher GPA, had to rely on long-distance applications, which paled in comparison to Sarah’s in-person networking advantages.

Beyond Jake and Sarah: Real-World Implications

The legal industry heavily favors candidates from local schools. Hiring managers prefer applicants who:

  • Are familiar with the state’s legal landscape and courts.
  • Can start working without needing to take another bar exam.
  • Have existing connections in the firm or city.

A 2023 hiring survey found that 80% of law firm recruiters preferred hiring from local schools over similarly ranked out-of-state schools. Many recruiters cited logistical ease, bar passage compatibility, and existing alumni as primary reasons.

Additionally, location isn’t just about the first job. Lawyers build their careers through ongoing networking and regional reputation. Being part of an established legal market early on offers long-term benefits:

  • Faster promotion opportunities due to deeper professional ties.
  • More visibility among recruiters when transitioning between firms.
  • Greater access to specialized legal fields, such as finance law in NYC or tech law in California.

If your dream is to work in Big Law in New York, Chicago, or D.C., attending a school in or near these cities gives you a significant head start.

Counterarguments: When Rankings Matter More

While location plays a dominant role, rankings are still critically important for students targeting the most prestigious law firms.

1. The National Reach of T14 Schools

Graduates from T14 law schools (Harvard, Yale, Stanford, etc.) can often overcome location disadvantages due to their schools’ national prestige. If you’re attending one of these schools, firms may recruit you regardless of where you study.

2. Niche Specializations

Certain areas of law, such as international arbitration or intellectual property law, may require going to a school that excels in that field, even if it’s outside a major city.

3. Strong Regional Schools Still Work

A highly-ranked school in a smaller city (e.g., the University of Virginia or the University of Michigan) still has strong placement power, but primarily in its own region.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Law School

Jake’s story is a warning: even top grades don’t guarantee top jobs if you’re not in the right market. Meanwhile, Sarah’s success illustrates how law school location can determine career outcomes.

When selecting a law school, ask yourself:

  1. Where do I want to work? Choose a school near that city.
  2. Does my target industry have regional hubs? Finance law? Go to NYC. Government law? D.C. Entertainment law? L.A.
  3. Will the school’s alumni network help me? If no, rethink your choice.
  4. Would a higher-ranked school offer me better long-term opportunities, even if it’s outside my target market?

Rankings matter, but proximity to opportunity is often more powerful. By choosing wisely, you can position yourself for long-term legal career success.

Similar Post